SEMI-HIGH SPEED (SHS) ON CURRENT INDIAN RAIL-TRACKS WITH CURRENT INFRASTRUCTURE – WILL IT BE SAFE?

TRACK QUALITY AND MAINTENANCE DEMANDS FOR INTRODUCING 160 KMPH SEMI-HIGH SPEED (SHS) PASSENGER TRAINS ON INDIAN RAILWAYS – SAFETY ISSUES

By Dr. F.A. Wingler, February 2019

The Challenge in Introducing Speeds of 160 kmph for Passenger Trains on IR is to meet the Demands for Initial and Inherent Quality of Track, to develop advanced Policy and Strategy in Infrastructure Management and modern best Practices of Permanent Work Procedures and mechanised Track-Maintenances. Policy and Strategy should be governed by Overall Life Cycle Costs Considerations. 160 kmph tracks have to be kept sound and healthy with high Track Quality Index (TGI) Values. Indian Railways should take lessons from recent Semi-High Speed (SHS) and High-Speed (HS) Train Crashes occurred in other Countries.

Prerequisites for 160 kmph are:

  • Well bearing and drained formation.
  • Long rolled rails of high steel-alloy quality.
  • High performance turnouts with condition monitoring sensors.
  • High standard robotic rail flash-but welding or digital controlled AT welding under supervision of well trained and skilled gangs.
  • Under sleeper pads for concrete sleepers and a fit-and-forget replacement rail-fastening system for the current Mark III ERC fastening.
  • Well planned, condition based and predictive modern mechanised maintenance practises and procedures executed with appropriated tools and heavy duty & high performance on-track machinery.
  • Regular preventive and target rail-grinding.
  • Deployment of automatic train protection/control.

The following Paper had been submitted to the  to the International Technical Seminar of I.P.W.E. (India), held on 22nd and 23rd Feb. 2019 at Hyderabad, with the topic: “Challenges in Introducing Speeds of 160 kmph for Passenger Trains on IR”.

INTEGRATED MULTI-MODAL PUBLIC METROPOLITAN TRANSPORT IN ISTANBUL

Public transport in Istanbul is an example of a successful integrated multi-modal urban and suburban public transport scheme in metropolitan area consisting of tram, metro-bus, underground metro, commuter railway, funicular, air-lift gondola and maritime-seaway (ferry-service and sea-bus) services for the more than 13 million inhabitants of the city spread over an area of 5712 km². The paper is composed of Wikipedia internet publications.

To learn more, download:ISTANBUL PUBLIC TRANSPORT SCHEME

METRO -Evolution of public Transport in urban and suburban metropolitan Area; a short History of World Metro Systems – in Pictures

“METRO” is the synonym for urban and suburban public integral transport. The evolution started 1863 in London with an underground steam railway as a metropolitan transport system. Metro public transport systems we find nowadays in about 180 cities around the globe. METRO has nowadays many faces, from rail guided underground and overground transits, over mono-rail, suspended sky-train, maglev, to waterway and ropeway transport.

 To learn more, download:

MATHERAN – AN ECOLOGICAL SENSITIVE HILLSTATION IN INDIA WITH POOR ROAD-INFRASTRUCTURE AND MASSIVE POLLUTION; TRANSPORT-SCHEMES; Part III By Dr. F.A. Wingler, February 2019

Matheran is ailing under poor road-access, poor road and trail conditions, air-pollution by stirred-up latertite-dust mixed with horse-dung and under waste-littering.

Programmes have commenced to bring betterments and to improve the road and cleanness situation. “Clean-Up Marshalls” advise now tourists not to litter the eco-sensitive zone and the beauty of the nature of Matheran.

After abolition of the brake porters on the 2 feet Narrow-Gauge Toy-Train, the introduction of the dual pipe, graduate release and indirect working compressed air-brake system in combination with the old 1903 bumpy tramway coupling system has resulted in hazardous train-set jerk and jolt movements, especially on down-gradient runs, that increase the derailment proneness. Therefore, the train-speed had to be reduced, which hampers a frequent train-service between Neral and Matheran. The Train-Drivers have to run trains, especially on down-gradient and on the poor aligned tight curves, in a snail`s pace with upmost vigilance, to avoid the risks of a derailment caused by train-set jerks. On 21th October 2018, a parcel-van of the shuttle service derailed on a turnout at Amman Lodge with a lucky narrow escape for the passengers in the adjacent coaches. Luckily the derailed parcel-van did not pull the passenger coaches from the track. Within the next 10 weeks 4 more coach derailments happened. Under modern Safety and Risk Management aspects, those unwanted bad events have to be investigated and treated as “NEAR MISSED BAD EVENTS” and therefore as “ACCIDENTS”. Lessons have to be learned.

The author suggests installing jerk- and jolt-movements free force locking railway couplers, as in use on the other Indian narrow gauge railways and on other narrow gauge heritage railways around the globe.

LUXURY is not needed; but SAFETY FOR THE PASSENGERS. This means: Luxury air-conditioned VISTA-DOM cars are not needed, but sound, healthy and well aligned rail-tracks and – in conjunction with the dual pipe compressed air brake system – force-locking state-of-the-art railway couplers.

COLOMBO SUBURBAN RAILWAY PROJECT (CSRP) – an ambitious Project; applicable and feasible technical Solutions

The ambitious Colombo Suburban Railway Project (CSRP) and the Colombo Suburban Efficiency Improvement Project aim to increase the share of rail transport from the current 5% to 10% by creating more demand for commuter rail transport through the provision of modern high capacity and rapid urban and suburban rail transport facilities. The success of the project will depend on whether it will be possible to bring the dilapidated railway-tracks up to sound and healthy high quality standards. The substructure of several rail-tracks is still at the level of the turn from the 19th century to the 20th century.

The re-engineering and strengthening of the railway-tracks by formation broadening and  strengthening will become  the most difficult task within the programme.

The Colombo Suburban Railway Project, CSRP, which is funded by Asian Development Bank, is also aiming at electrification of the section from Veyangoda to Panadura (64 km) in the Colombo Suburban Area of Sri Lanka.

Obstacle for a higher commuter ridership by rail  are the low rail-route capacity, the long station to station journey time (transit-time), the over-packed commuter trains in peak hours with low customer satisfaction.

A high capacity and rapid suburban commuter rail service with customer satisfaction needs sound and healthy rail tracks of high inherent quality with low deterioration rates under given traffic load. Decisive factors are

  • well bearing, well drained and broad track substructure components (subsoil, subgrade, formation, formation protective layer and ballast),
  • high performance track layouts with state-of-the-art turnout and crossing technology and design,
  • modern signaling with train protection,
  • fast accelerating and decelerating high capacity and well maintained rolling stocks with reliable break system.

The question is not: Diesel or electric traction. What matters and hampers the current rail-service for a higher commuter ridership, bringing travelers from road to rail, are

  • the long station to station journey (transit) times and over-packed trains during peak hour,
  • the low route capacity with long headways,
  • the existing poor quality rail-tracks on narrow, badly drained and yielding formation of insufficient bearing capacity,
  • the unfavorable track design-layouts with turnouts and crossing of outdated technical design hampering higher route capacity,
  • the complex color light signaling system (with about 60 valid aspects in use) without any train protection and not allowing short headways.
  • the poor and improper service, repair and maintenance of the rolling stocks,
  • the limited capacity of maintenance depots and sheds,
  • the neglected and improper service, repair, maintenance, tests, examinations and certification of the train-brake systems before dispatching trains to run.

Before electric traction can come on Srilankan tracks, the current main problems, shortcomings, deficiencies and bottlenecks of Sri Lanka Railway have to be addressed first of all.

However, electric traction needs a reliable power supply with sufficient redundancy. This is not given in Sri Lanka. The scope of capital investment is exorbitant high and must be in a relation to the savings gathered by the electric running trains. In the section Panadura-Veyangoda, electric traction will favor only the short-distance running local trains and not the other long distance trains. The savings gathered through electric traction of only a part of the trains do not justify the high capital-investment expenses.

In case of the Kelani-Valley Line, since long the author suggests renovating the KV railway with Meter-Gauge and Y-shaped ThyssenKrupp Steel-Sleepers, as well to render the commuter train service with modern Light Weight Diesel Rail-Cars of Type Stadler-Bussnang, Switzerland, with middle module Diesel-electric power-pack traction instead with the heavy power-sets Class S8, S9, S19, S11 or S12. In tight curves, Light Weight Rail-Cars on winding Y-steel-sleeper tracks can run with higher speed than conventional heavy power-sets on concretes-sleeper tracks.

Modern Light Weight Rail-Car Technology (see INNOTRANS 2018, 18-21. 09, Berlin, Germany) and Y-shaped Steel-Sleepers make it possible to operate a modern high capacity and rapid commuter rail-services on winding trace with Meter-Gauge and as well on 760 mm (2 ½ feet) Narrow-Gauge as demonstrated by advanced railways in  North Spain, Austria, Switzerland and Germany.

On the route to Kandy, the low route capacity and slow train speed on the Balana-Incline between Rambukkanna and Kadugannawa is a severe bottleneck. This section has to be renovated by slope- and rock-stabilization, rock-fall protection, widening of bearing formation and revamping the side and catch drains. The rails should be laid as Long Welded Rails (LWR) on a well ballasted track-bed with Y-ThyssenKrupp steel-sleepers, that will give the track excellent geometry stability on the narrow and winding trace.

Modern sound and healthy state-of-the-art rail-tracks of high quality with modern signaling cum train protection will increase the route-capacity, cut station-to-station journey time, shorten headways, and last not least will bring more traffic from road onto rail and will increase the demand for rail-transport. For this target, costly electrification is not needed.

The technical railway paper contributes applicable and feasible technical solutions and reveals, what can be learned from advanced railways in Europe.

To learn more, download: CSRP – FEASIBLE SOLUTIONS 3